The bot can go second

AI can help you write. But should it be the one coming up with the ideas?

Don’t get bot hurt. Get bot even.

Bot Talk

Your story. But does it feel like yours?

Letting AI do more of the writing doesn't necessarily save time. It might just make everyone's stories sound more alike.

Researchers studying 285 college students found that people who let AI handle everything from brainstorming to editing produced less interesting work and reported lower satisfaction than those who remained involved in the creative process.

The study, published in PNAS Nexus, a peer-reviewed journal of the National Academy of Sciences, compared three approaches: letting AI lead while humans approved the results, having humans develop ideas before AI drafted and collaborating with AI throughout.

Participants wrote stories without AI and then with AI assistance using one of the three approaches.

All three AI-assisted approaches took roughly the same amount of time. But when AI took the creative lead, the stories were more similar to one another, and their writers reported less satisfaction with the writing process.

By contrast, keeping humans involved in developing ideas and outlines produced more distinctive work without taking more time than the other AI-assisted approaches.

Human × Bot

The bot doesn't get the last word

Remember the bestselling author we met in New Orleans who was worried about AI replacing writers? Then she saw what AI could actually write and wasn't nearly as worried.

The research in Bot Talk gives us another reason to appreciate the human side of writing. There's more to a good story than putting words on a page.

Which brings us to a little behind-the-scenes look at Bot Hurt.

AI has helped keep this newsletter going. And lately, with busy schedules and Thursdays arriving suspiciously fast, the bot has sometimes gotten the first word.

When we haven't had time to comb through the latest AI news, we might start by asking ChatGPT what's happening, what might interest readers and which stories deserve a closer look. Other weeks, we bring an idea, a question or something we've spotted ourselves.

Either way, the bot joins the editorial meeting.

It helps us research, explore angles, challenge assumptions and polish copy. Sometimes it pitches a story we hadn't considered. Sometimes we pitch one that needs a little work. And sometimes we go back and forth until we've got something worth publishing.

But the bot doesn't get a byline, an editor's chair or the final say.

We still decide what's newsworthy, check the facts and make sure the finished story sounds like Bot Hurt. AI can help us get there, but the editorial judgment stays with us.

So yes, sometimes the bot goes first. It just doesn't get the last word.

Final Bot Thought

Good ideas can come from anywhere. Knowing which ones matter is still your job.